Thursday, June 30, 2016


Parenting over Punishment
 
There are no step by step guides or cliff notes to parenting. Physical punishment like spanking or verbal punishment like yelling can stop a behavior issues in its tracks, but it never has any long lasting effect other than for children to associate fear with bad behavior, rather than teaching a lesson of comprehension to change the child’s long term behavior. 

It seems like a simple concept to not punish but rather parent but it is sometimes difficult to put into place unless we practice techniques and learn how to not react.

The first step is to look at negative behavior in a different way.  After we have asked our children five times to complete a task and then still haven’t done so we get frustrated and use our mature adult parent mind and think, “ why can’t my child just do this…I have asked five times already?”  Are they doing this to make me mad?

Here are some quick tips to keep in mind when frustration sets in.

1.    Child won’t clean up toys or do chores.

 

Parent: "When will I be able to relax until all of this stuff is put away so I can relax and cook dinner?"

 

Child: "I want to get out more stuff because I am bored with what is here and maybe go play a video game or see what my friends are doing.  Wait…I want to make a fort with all the stuff I have out now."

 

Solution: Think like a child. Children’s brains are not fully developed to think like an adult.  The more you come to their level, the more you will establish trust and cooperation with them.

Make it into a game.  My daughter and I once pretended we were in a forest and we had to put all the rainbow loads of laundry away before it got dark and the rainbow would disappear.   The laundry detergent was the magic power to make the rainbow have protective powers to stop the darkness. My daughter was so engaged she wondered if it was safe to back in the forest to do laundry again.  I assured her there always will be rainbows, (loads of laundry).

 

 

2.    Child is bored

Parent: “I wish I could say I was bored.  I am so busy I can hardly breathe.”

Child: “They won’t let me watch tv or play games or go on the computer.  My parents are so mean and I am bored.”

Solution:  Children need to be engaged.  Pull out a board game or Yatzee which young kids can play by shaking the dice. Art projects are always engaging. Make a fort or an obstacle course in your home.

Involve your child in everything you do including getting the mail or picking items off the shelves when shopping.  It gives them a sense of purpose and a job to do. Give them an incentive with an allowance so they understand the value of work.  Kids do not always have to be engaged with you directly. This is not a reason to hand them an electronic device and walk away, but they certainly can build and create a lot without parents having to be one on one at all times.

If children are engaged they will not be bored.  Again you can use some creativity and a childlike mentality to motivate them.  Getting the mail can be going to outer space to get the special delivery from the space shuttle!

3.    Child is very upset or crying

Parent: “Oh no, my child fell down and is probably going to cry really loud.  I have to make sure that my child does not create a scene, that I am a perfect parent.  People are going to think I did something tragically wrong.  I just want my child to be happy.”

Child: “I just got hurt and my first instinct is to cry out for Mom or Dad because that is what I have done since I was born and that is all I know how to do.  It doesn’t hurt that bad but if they come to me and hug me and kiss my hurt I know things will be better.  I just need to be comforted.”

My first recommendation is to not react when your child gets hurt.  Don’t show a face of panic. You know the dropped jaw parent that can’t keep it together when their child is hurt.   Be calm and cool like an EMT would be in rescuing someone.  Emergency workers don’t show up saying oh my gosh what am I go to do in panic, they show up and start doing what needs to be done on mission to save lives. 

Put on that face and go to your child.  Make sure you acknowledge even the tiniest scrape or even no scrape and assure them they will be ok. Avoid saying oh it’s nothing.  To the child it is a very intense experience—remember they don’t have 30 or 40 years or experience getting hurt like adults do.  Everything to children is a very new experience.

Or

Child: “I am not getting my way.  All I wanted was that treat in the aisle at the grocery store and my parents won’t let me.  I am going to throw a fit until they give in and just get it for me.”

Time to wheel and deal.  Yes it sounds like being a used car salesperson but you have to set boundaries for your kids.

“How much is that candy bar?” 

“It is $1.50”. 

“How many loads of laundry would it take to pay for that candy bar?”

 First you are distracting them from the whole idea of the candy bar, creating an opportunity to do with math, and seeing if that value is worth it to the child. 

You can’t do this with younger kids who do not receive allowances but you can make it into a teaching opportunity. 
Another idea that works is replacement.  Well if we get the candy bar today we can’t have ice cream Sundaes for dinner.  Would you rather not have ice cream Sundaes for dinner?

Or

Child: "I am not self-aware that I am over hungry or tired and that affects my ability to make good choices or that my behavior could affect others."

This is a tricky one.  This is when kids’ physiological needs are not being met. If the child is either hungry, thirsty, tired or all of those, there is no other cure that meeting those needs.

Start with water.  Kids don’t spend all day drinking water like adults do.  They are likely not hydrated which is a lack of O2 in the body. 
Bring them to a different place.  Sometimes changing the environment changes the mood.  This can be done in other situations when kids are upset as well.  Ask your child, what is your body telling you?

Parenting over Punishment key items to remember

Think like a child and remember children do not have all the experiences that adults have already experienced many times in life.

Be creative and get to your child’s level.  Have patience and keep your cool in heated times.   

If you sound like your parents or how an adult talked to you when you were younger, in a scolding tone, you need to rethink your technique in terms of parenting rather than punishment.

 

 From the Author: My goal is that my articles help parents with raising children and would love to hear tips from you as well.  Feel free to respond to this blog. I am an Art Director and Teacher and previous Technical Writer and enjoy researching and writing about care for children. 

Julie Gahona

 

 

These are some resources from courses I have taken or resources that I use for information and recommend for more knowledge on parenting:

 

Positive Parenting

Focus on the Family

Love and Logic

STEAM courses